Simulation Overview

The AREPO Code

The PICO-Cluster simulations were carried out with the AREPO code (AREPO-2 version), a moving-mesh magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) code evolved from the MillenniumTNG project. Collisionless components (dark matter, stars, SMBHs) are modelled as discrete particles with gravitational forces computed using a TreePM approach. The ICM gas is represented on an unstructured Voronoi mesh that follows the gas motion, providing the benefits of Lagrangian schemes. AREPO-2 features advances in memory management, load-balancing efficiency, and the Subfind-HBT algorithm for efficient merger tree construction.

MHD is evolved using a second-order finite-volume Godunov scheme with the HLLD Riemann solver. Divergence errors in the magnetic field are controlled with the Powell 8-wave scheme. Simulations are initialized with a uniform comoving magnetic seed field of 10−14 G at z = 127.

IllustrisTNG Galaxy Formation Model

The baseline physics incorporates the full IllustrisTNG galaxy formation model, including:

The IllustrisTNG model was calibrated on 25 h−1Mpc volumes; PICO-Clusters tests it in the extreme cluster environment at unprecedented resolution.

Simulation Parameters

ParameterValue
Parent box size1 h−1Gpc
Parent box particles10243 DM
Clusters in parent272 (M>1015 M)
Zoom simulations24
Zoom factorsZ4, Z8, Z12, Z24
Main zoom levelZ12
Contamination-free>2.7 R200 all times
Seed B-field10−14 G (comoving)
Init. redshiftz = 127
CosmologyPlanck 2018
Ωm0.316
Ωb0.049
h0.673
σ80.81

Resolution Levels

PICO-Clusters are re-simulated at zoom factors 4, 8, 12, and 24 relative to the parent simulation

Zoom Factor DM Particle Mass (M) Baryonic Cell Mass (M) DM Softening (h−1kpc) Comparable to
Z4 1.6×109 3.0×108 4.88 ~TNG300-2.5
Z8 2.0×108 3.7×107 2.44 ~MTNG
Z12 (main) 5.9×107 1.1×107 1.63 ~TNG300 / TNG-Cluster
Z24 (halo 4) 7.4×106 1.4×106 0.81 ~TNG100 (but 7× more massive)

The Z24 simulation of halo 4 (M200 = 2.7×1015 M) is the highest-resolution IllustrisTNG simulation of a galaxy cluster above 1015 M.

Resolution convergence

Convergence study of halo 4 at zoom factors Z4, Z8, Z12, and Z24. Rows show gas density, vorticity, magnetic field strength, and mock optical images. Higher resolutions reveal additional low-mass subhalos and finer turbulent structures. View full size →

Initial Conditions & Cluster Selection

CosmoZoomIC

Zoom-in initial conditions were created with the new CosmoZoomIC code (Puchwein et al., in prep.). The code uses a hierarchical tree structure to concentrate resolution in the Lagrangian region of each cluster and its environment out to 5 R200, allowing the high-resolution zone to trace the arbitrarily shaped Lagrangian volume, with a gradual transition to the coarse background grid.

Two key techniques prevent contamination by low-resolution particles:

All clusters are confirmed free of contamination within at least 2.74 R200 at all simulation outputs, with the typical minimum contamination radius exceeding 4 R200.

Contamination radius

Left: minimum contamination radius vs. cluster mass for all simulations. Right: density distributions of high- and low-resolution particles at z=0. View full size →

Parent Box & Halo Selection

Clusters were selected from a 1 h−1Gpc non-radiative MHD parent simulation with 10243 DM particles (Planck 2018 cosmology). All 272 halos above 1015 M were identified at z = 0.

The 24 selected clusters have a flat distribution in log(M200) between 1014.9 and 1015.4 M, with the five most massive halos always included. This mass range extends well beyond the most massive clusters in TNG100 (3.8×1014 M) and TNG50 (1.8×1014 M).

Parent box and zoom-in

The parent simulation showing the cosmic web (left), a string of clusters (lower right), and the Z24 zoom-in re-simulation of halo 4 (upper right). View full size →

The PICO-Cluster Sample

24 clusters at zoom factor Z12 (plus convergence study of halo 4 at Z4, Z8, Z24)

# Halo Zoom M500 [1015 M] M200 [1015 M] min(Rmin/R200) Physics versions Image at z=0
click for full size
10122.0093.3044.57TNG Halo 0
21122.0762.9162.74TNG Halo 1
32121.5672.8513.72TNG Halo 2
43121.9722.7203.12TNGNONRAD Halo 3
544/8/12/241.743–1.8792.721–2.7323.31–5.00TNGNONRAD Halo 4
68122.1922.8304.21TNG Halo 8
79121.6992.5003.93TNG Halo 9
819121.5992.1094.60TNG Halo 19
922121.3472.0723.97TNG Halo 22
1033121.3531.8184.84TNG Halo 33
1141121.1641.7293.37TNG Halo 41
1249121.0241.6173.91TNG Halo 49
1356120.9551.5774.75TNG Halo 56
1498120.9971.3644.02TNG Halo 98
15104120.9361.3543.62TNG Halo 104
16112120.9391.3292.91TNG Halo 112
17194120.6011.0344.40TNGNONRAD Halo 194
18239120.7281.0714.50TNGJET Halo 239
19260120.6811.1493.79TNGJETNONRAD Halo 260
20261120.6150.9894.21TNG Halo 261
21344120.6640.9324.53TNG Halo 344
22417120.5470.8584.41TNG Halo 417
23420120.5300.8852.87TNGJET Halo 420
24542120.4400.7513.80TNG Halo 542

Masses are at z = 0 in the zoom-in IllustrisTNG simulation. min(Rmin/R200) is the minimum over all output times of the closest lower-resolution particle. All clusters are contamination-free within at least 2.74 R200. Physics versions: TNG = IllustrisTNG galaxy formation model; JET = explicit AGN jet feedback; NONRAD = non-radiative MHD (no cooling, star formation, or feedback).

Cluster sample gas density

Gas density projections of all 24 PICO-Cluster galaxy clusters at Z12 resolution at z=0. Circles indicate R200. View full size →